Courtesy Indianapolis Fire Department

Just one-and-a-half miles southeast of the Circle on one of our city’s original diagonal streets, Fountain Square is thriving today with unique restaurants, galleries, night clubs, and not just one, but two duck pin bowling alleys.

This 1950s view looks northwest from Prospect Street along the Virginia Avenue commercial corridor. The negative was taken from the vantage point of the fountain that gives the neighborhood its name. Businesses lining the street include Schiff’s Shoes, Merchants National Bank (building constructed in 1922 and designed by architects Vonnegut, Bohn, and Mueller), G. C. Murphy Co. Five and Dime, Gus Kasper Furniture and Appliances, and Wade’s Drug Store.

Google Street View, July 2009

As a preservationist, I’m always happy when the “now” photograph nearly matches the “then.” This 2009 view reveals that the buildings remain mostly unchanged. Occupants today include the Mexican Grill, PNC Bank (still National City in 2009), and the Murphy Building houses galleries, artist studios, and restaurants. The Fountain Block Building on the right was constructed in 1902 with stores on the first floor, offices and apartments above, and a grand hall on the upper floor. In 1994 the Fountain Block was rehabbed to its current configuration and today houses the Fountain Square Branch of the Indianapolis Public Library and Fountain View Senior Apartments.

4 responses to “Indianapolis Then and Now: Virginia Avenue at Prospect”

  1. KurtL says:

    I really like the Red Lion and the shops.

  2. basil a berchekas jr says:

    Would love to see the pre-auto photos with trolleys, if they were available somewhere; these are darned good, though!

  3. AricF says:

    The 1950s view is a designers dream. All of the signage and billboards. Neat comparison and look into the past.

  4. Jim Walsh says:

    The autos in this photos look much newer than autos from the late 50’s, plus there are not ETB wires, unless this picture was take after March 9th 1957 there show be ETB wires, again these cars are much newer than 50’s cars

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *