Thumbing through stacks of postcards, on the hunt for pictures and stories from a particular town … in a particular time frame, I’ve discovered that it’s inevitable to find duplicates. Imagine the postcard rack in any town you’ve ever visited. There are anywhere from ten to 50 copies of the same card available for purchase. Since beginning the Penny Post feature, I’ve noticed a trend in which Indianapolis images are most popular (the Monument … and the former bear cage at Riverside Park). The more I look through the cards, the more I find something so endearing about the “duplicates.” Researching this week’s post, I ran across a collector’s comment that no two postcards are ever exactly the same – not to the sender or the receiver.

As students across Indianapolis clatter back into their classrooms, this week’s Penny Post features three Shortridge High School postcards. The first two images are from an earlier incarnation of Shortridge, the third is what still stands on Meridian Street–all three reveal very different stories where the sender is concerned.


1. Shortridge High School Postmarked: Indianapolis, IND, Dec. 8, 1905 – 4 PM


Image courtesy

Sat. Morning –
Have been so rushed with work and have so much to write, am so tired and dirty to do a thing. The coat is just fine. Mom’s and Flo’s letters came. Will write today.
lots of love, MW


Image courtesy

Addressed to:
Mrs. Martin S. Webster
12 Maple Street
Auburn, New York


2. Shortridge High School, Indianapolis, Ind. Postmarked: Indianapolis, IND 2, Jul 23, 1928 – 3:30 PM


Image courtesy


Image courtesy

From Aunt Mary

Addressed to:
Mr. Paul Humer
35 Walker St
Tiffin, Ohio


3. Shortridge High School and Caleb Mills Hall, Indianapolis, Ind. – 30 Postmarked: Indianapolis, IND., Apr 7, 1946 – 6PM


Image courtesy


Shortridge High School, successor of the old Indianapolis High School, located at 34th and Meridian Streets. Enrollment 3,500 pupils, work devoted largely to preparation for college.
Image courtesy

Will be very happy to exchange with you.
Miss Pat Schuesler
505 Warren Ave.
Indianapolis, 3, ind.

Addressed to:
Earl W. Walker
222 14th St.
Vallejo, Calif.

A penny for your thoughts … What interests me about these three cards is that they represent the variety of ways people use postcards to send messages to friends, family, acquiescence and potential strangers. In 1905, during the rise of the Golden Era of the Postcard, many people sent their penny posts to let others know that they would be sending a letter soon. Perhaps the historic equivalent of “I’ll call you in a few.” Others, like Aunt Mary, might have sent a postcard  just to let someone know they are thinking of them. Although I do wonder why Aunt Mary picked a Shortridge postcard – was nephew Paul an alumni or was it the most handy card at the moment?

I was most intrigued by the 1946 card sent by Miss Pat Schuesler to Vallejo, California. According to the 1947 city directory, Patty Schuesler worked for the Veterans of Foreign Wars.  It was also interesting to look at where 505 Warren Ave. is located within the city. The Schuesler house once sat in the J.H. Clark 2nd Addition neighborhood on the city’s west side, directly south of General Motor’s Chevrolet Commercial Body plant and north of the (closed) Hoffa’s Silver Cafe (down the street from what is now Carniceria Gaunajuato). Today, most of the homes in the Schuesler’s neighborhood are paved over, fenced off parking lots or neglected buildings like the Albert R. Worm building previously featured here and here.


The 1947 Indianapolis City Directory lists Patty Schuesler’s occupation as “sten Veterans of Foreign Wars” and her residence as 505 Warren Ave.


This Indianapolis Baist Atlas Plan #29 from 1929 points to the approximate location of the Schuesler’s house. Many of the homes shown on the map are now gone.
Image from the IUPUI Indianapolis Sanborn Map and Baist Atlas Collection


Tell us, do these Shortridge High School postcards inspire any memories from you?



If you have an Indianapolis postcard you think would be an interesting contribution to the Penny Post, please let me know!